Skip to main content

Perfectionism as a Risk Factor for Anxiety & Depression

Matthew Davies
April 12, 2025

1. Defining Perfectionism: More Than Just High Standards

Perfectionism is often mistaken for simple diligence—an admirable drive to do things well. But clinically, perfectionism is more insidious than that. It is not just about setting high standards; it is about tying one’s self-worth to those standards and fearing failure as a reflection of personal inadequacy. When perfectionistic tendencies become rigid, they create a breeding ground for anxiety and depression.

There is an important distinction between adaptive and maladaptive perfectionism. Adaptive perfectionists aim high but can tolerate mistakes and setbacks. Maladaptive perfectionists, however, struggle with an unrelenting need for flawlessness, often experiencing distress when their own impossible expectations are not met. Perfectionism, in this sense, is like a treadmill set to an ever- increasing speed—no matter how fast one runs, the destination remains out of reach.


Perfectionist

“Perfectionism acts like an invisible cage—it provides the illusion of safety while restricting meaningful engagement with life.”

2. Perfectionism and Anxiety: The Fear of Making Mistakes

Perfectionism often reflects cognitive distortions — an error in thinking that magnifies the significance of flaws and failures. Many perfectionists engage in catastrophic thinking, in which they interpret even minor mistakes as potential disasters. A student who gets a B on an exam may believe it will ruin their entire academic future. A professional who misspeaks in a meeting might dwell on the moment for weeks, convinced they have damaged their reputation beyond repair.

This fear of making mistakes often leads to avoidance behaviours. Perfectionists procrastinate—not out of laziness, but because the pressure to meet their own unrealistic expectations is paralysing. When they do complete tasks, they may engage in over-checking, excessive revisions, or rigid
routines, all in an attempt to prevent perceived failure. Ironically, these behaviours do not alleviate anxiety; they reinforce it by convincing the individual that success only comes through exhaustive effort and self-punishment.

For socially anxious individuals, perfectionism extends beyond work and academics—it shapes their interactions with others. They believe they must always be articulate, interesting, and likable, and they avoid situations where they might appear awkward or imperfect. This fear of social evaluation fuels isolation, preventing them from testing the very assumptions that drive their anxiety. In this way, perfectionism acts like an invisible cage—it provides the illusion of safety while restricting meaningful engagement with life.


3. Perfectionism and Depression: When Standards Become Self-Punishment

While anxiety fuels the constant drive to perform, depression often follows when perfectionists
inevitably fall short. Perfectionism is a self-defeating cycle—one in which individuals set unattainable goals, experience distress when they fail, and then engage in harsh self-criticism. This internal dialogue is frequently filled with cognitive distortions such as black-and-white thinking (“If I don’t excel, I’m a failure”) and overgeneralization (“I always let people down”).

The research is clear: perfectionism is a significant risk factor for major depressive disorder (MDD). A meta-analysis by Smith et al. (2018) found that perfectionistic concerns—particularly those related to self-criticism and fear of failure—are predictive of depressive symptoms. One reason for this link
is that perfectionists struggle to derive satisfaction from their achievements. Even when they succeed, their sense of accomplishment is fleeting because their expectations quickly shift upward.

They are left in a perpetual state of striving without reward, which, over time, fosters feelings of hopelessness. Like climbing an endless staircase, each step forward only reveals another flight of steps, with no summit in sight.


4. Perfectionism Across Development: Early Roots and Personality Traits

Where does perfectionism come from? While no single cause explains it entirely, several developmental factors play a role.

  1. Parenting and Early Experiences – Children who grow up in highly critical or achievement-focused environments often internalize the belief that love and acceptance are contingent on success. If mistakes are met with disproportionate consequences, they may develop an excessive fear of failure.

  2. High-Achieving Environments – Schools and workplaces that reward only the highest performers can reinforce perfectionistic thinking. When effort and improvement are overlooked in favour of flawless execution, individuals may learn to equate their worth with their performance.

  3. Personality Traits – Perfectionism is often associated with high conscientiousness and neuroticism—two traits that, when combined, create a tendency toward both meticulousness and emotional reactivity. While conscientiousness can be beneficial, neuroticism amplifies the fear of failure, making perfectionistic tendencies more rigid and distressing.


5. Cognitive-Behavioural Perspectives on Treating Perfectionism

Cognitive-behavioural therapy (CBT) provides a well-supported framework for addressing perfectionism. One of the primary interventions is cognitive restructuring, in which clients are guided to identify and challenge unhelpful beliefs about failure and self-worth. Some common techniques include:

  • Identifying automatic thoughts – Clients learn to recognize perfectionistic thinking patterns,
    such as “If I don’t do this perfectly, I’ve failed.”
  • Testing assumptions – Therapists encourage behavioural experiments where client deliberately make small mistakes to see if their feared outcomes actually occur.
  • Reframing mistakes – Clients are helped to view errors as opportunities for growth rather than evidence of incompetence.

Another critical approach is exposure therapy. Because perfectionism is maintained by avoidance, clients are encouraged to engage in activities that challenge their rigid standards—such as submitting a draft without over-editing or allowing themselves to be vulnerable in social situations. Over time, these experiences help reduce the fear associated with imperfection.

Self-compassion is also an essential component of treatment. Perfectionists often struggle with self- kindness, treating themselves with an inner harshness they would never apply to others.

Encouraging clients to respond to setbacks with curiosity rather than condemnation can help break the cycle of self-criticism and emotional distress.


6. Moving Toward Adaptive Standards: A More Sustainable Approach

Addressing perfectionism does not mean abandoning high standards—it means cultivating psychological flexibility. Some key shifts that promote well-being include:

  • Focusing on progress over outcomes – Learning to appreciate incremental improvements rather than all-or-nothing success.
  • Recognizing effort as valuable in itself – Shifting from external validation to intrinsic satisfaction.
  • Developing distress tolerance – Learning that mistakes and discomfort are part of growth, rather than signals of failure.

Ultimately, perfectionism thrives on the illusion that flawlessness is attainable and necessary. The more one chases it, the more elusive it becomes. In therapy, the goal is not to dismantle ambition or drive, but to create a healthier, more sustainable relationship with achievement—one that allows space for imperfection, resilience, and genuine fulfillment.

For those struggling with perfectionism, the first step is often recognizing that it is not a personal failing, but a learned pattern of thinking—one that can, with time and effort, be reshaped into something more life-affirming. And if that process feels imperfect? Well, that’s exactly the point.